A few months ago I posted on converting my old 35mm and APS film to digital pictures. Since then, I've done about 50 rolls through Scan Cafe and taking film into Target stores to be put on CD.
The Good:
- I can actually see pictures now on my computer where I spend time each day versus old albums in the guest bedroom that I never pick up.
- Scan Cafe customer service was good. I got a bad DVD at first and they sent me a new copy right away.
The Bad:
- Quality isn't great. Scan Cafe did a good job creating high resolution images but when they were originally taken with a cheap point and shoot camera or even a disposable camera, what's the point of the high res?
- Scan Cafe allows you to pay for just the scans that you want to keep. However, their web site for viewing your photos is horrible at best. It's excruciatingly painfully slow and only displays a crappy small version of your photo. The photo review part of that experience seriously couldn't have been worse. I'm not sure if they are trying to prevent people from simply downloading photos instead of paying for them or if they just hate their customers but either way, it was really bad. They allow for renaming folders for organization but that does not carry over to the DVD they send. Scan Cafe allows for rotating but that also does not carry over to the DVD. They claim they do manual photo retouching, however, most of my pics that came back appeared to be untouched and benefited greatly from cheap contrast adjustments using Picasa. Scan Cafe allows you to delete photos that you do not want to pay for; great, except they send you the deleted ones too. I guess that is good if you know about it, but I deleted the poorly shot, dark, and blurry photos and was forced to wade through them again when I got the DVD.
- Target is on to me and started charging $7 per roll of APS film to be transferred to a Kodak Picture CD. This is still cheaper than sending APS to Scan Cafe.
In the end, the ability to have digital versions of my pictures out-weighs the bad and I'll continue to send 35 mm to Scan Cafe and take a few rolls of APS at a time to my local Target store.